Pakistani Hackers Take Down French Magazine Website for Publishing Blasphemous Cartoons

Charlie HebdoPakistani hackers have taken down Charlie Hebdo website, a Satirical Weekly Magazine, which published cartoons of Prophet Mohammad (P.B.U.H) in its edition today.

Official website of Charlie Hebdo was immediately taken down by a group of Pakistani hackers, who claim to have targeted the website for publishing blasphemous cartoons.

Website, when last checked, was still inaccessible.

Hacker group which calls itself “Guardian of Honor of Prophet SAW” told ProPakistani over phone that insult of Prophet SAW led them to take this extreme step.

Charlie Hebdo magazine website is currently showing “Website Inaccessible” message, which is apparently short of resources due to a DoS attack. “Guardian of Honor of Prophet SAW” group is confident that they can keep the website down for indefinite time, until they realize their mistake.

In an email communication a member of hacker group wrote to ProPakistani:

The movement has begun, it will rise from heart of every Muslim regardless of age, color, cast and creed, with an aim to preach the masses that Freedom of Speech for hurting the sentiments of Muslims across the world is simply not acceptable.

Dual standards are evidently shown when the free speech is about holocaust but the world least care when they put blasphemous contents about our Prophet SAW.

We will fight till our last drop of blood. We don’t promote violence, instead we peacefully put the down the website that had posted blasphemous content today.

We are ready to close down any blasphemous content published by any group using sophisticated TCP SYN attacks.

This move also shows the world that Muslims can protest in a more peaceful and technological way, instead of killing innocent people.

The French government speaks about freedom of speech, where was the freedom of speech and religion, when they banned Burqa and hijab in france?

We are not a hacker organization or a group, We just demand justice for the hypocrisy that’s going on in the name of ‘freedom of speech’, If the government
is not taking any action against so called blatant freedom of speech, We will do whatever is necessary to stop the blasphemous content of our holy prophet, and the whole Muslim Ummah is behind us.

Tech reporter with over 10 years of experience, founder of ProPakistani.PK


      • “Live and let live “is something yet to be learned….
        Martin Luther King taught us tolerance and peace …
        in the face of those who disagree…

        • Sorry Sam, people are a little naive sometimes. I love my Prophet Muhammad (P.B.U.H) and although these “Muslims” react in such way, they definitely need to work on their religion as Islam certainly prohibits such actions.

          • They don’t realize that their love for Our Prophet cannot exceed the boundaries set by Allah. If they destroy a Muslim’s property while protesting some embassy, they are criminals.

        • Indeed it is Sam, well said. First poke us then ask us to live and let live.

          What do they say about people who live in glass houses?

          • Yes, a mad man, one person who lied about his nationality, religion, name, etc. made a movie, and hundreds if not thousands of Muslims have been injured in “protests” and several killed also, and countries browught to a standstill.

            Can you calculate the economic loss we have inflicted on ourselves in the past two weeks?

    • Smart and techo lead way to protest!!
      US and West has once again proof they are bias and double standadred.
      Why speaking against holocust is prohobited? infact illegal in many western countries? what happen to freedom of expression?? is it because it never happen or very limited and JEWS are capitalizing it and its a propagnda just like weapon of mass destruction.

      Then Americans wonders WHY WORLD HATES US :).
      I have one word them “RETARDED” :)

  • Muslim all over the world have demonstrated what they felt and its the right way to show the protest.

      • Y dnt u shut the entire world
        Computers laptops smartphones they are all made by the ones who insulted
        And while you are at it stop using electricity too it was also founded by one of them and paper was introduced by the chinese who btw arnt related to them but well while u r at it y nt make them pay as well

        • SO WHAT? IF THEY INSULT ISLAM I WILL SHUT ELECTRICITY TOO. AND IF YOU DEFEND THE INFIDELS THIS WAY YOU ARE NOT A MUSLIM.

          • Better get started. Our transformers, power supplies, computers, power stations — all designed & built by non-Muslims who do not want to be Muslims.

            did you get a signed statement when you bought your computer that no one who worked on any of the components does not hate Islam? Nope.

            • Shahid bhai, no need to be a retard. If non muslims are selective in insulting us and prosecuting muslims, we too, can be selective in protesting against a video, a particular site, etc. while using things made by western countries.

              Ofcourse, lets not forget, the scientific advances made by Muslims, which were later stolen by Europeans led to these technologies and discoveries.

              • Shutting down mobile services in Pakistan will not affect a single person in the West responsible for making or distributing that movie.

                Seems like the protest is targetted against Muslims in Pakistan.

                — Ofcourse, lets not forget, the scientific advances made by Muslims, which were later stolen by Europeans led to these technologies and discoveries.

                They stole nothing, we simply stopped advancing ON OUR OWN because the scientists became in conflict with RELIGIOUS PEOPLE OF THEIR TIME. Do no lie about our history to me.

                • ISLAM IS SACRED. MIND YOUR WORDS WHAT ARE YOU SAYING. IF WE STOP USING THERE COMPUTERS AND ELECTRICITY THEY WILL BECOME BANKRUPT. THAN WE CAN ASK THAT UNO MUST HAVE A BLASPHEMY LAW LIKE PAKISTAN. WE WILL TEACH THE WORLD A LESSON. WAIT AND SEE.

                • Scientist will have conflicting problems, because when we are thinking, we don’t tend to think by keeping our self into the boundaries, set by ISLAM. Its where the ULAMA have to tell them not to think that way.
                  For example, As a doctor myself, I see science has brought that “DONOR SPERM (meaning three people make a baby)” a practice which in ISLAMIC ways isn’t acceptable at any case. Most of the theologians end up thinking otherwise and why because it occurred due to not being in touch with ULAMA + the less we stick to the religion by ACTIONS, the more astray we get.

                  In this ERA of technology and easy exposure to lots of information, MUHAMMAD ( PBUH ) said,(interpretation) During the end of the times, there will be less intelligent people and more …….

                  No offence at all, Just a Point of View!

      • Khursheed sahab, no need to be a retard. If non muslims are selective in insulting us and prosecuting muslims, we too, can be selective in protesting against a video, a particular site, etc. while using things made by western countries.

        Ofcourse, lets not forget, the scientific advances made by Muslims, which were later stolen by Europeans led to these technologies and discoveries.

    • Agreed. but sad to see our so called “educated” pakistanis making derogatory and hateful comments against this group. On one hand these “educated” elitist burgers are saying no violence, no hate. And yet they themselves hate this group now. Double standards not only of the west, but also of these 2 number pakistanis.

      • No one here made a hateful comment. If you think so, point to it, and then point to the sentence in it that spread HATE.

        So many people here think disagreement = hate. YOU HAVE ALREADY LOST MENTALLY.

  • Very good work. We should ban youtube. And google also. Time to ban Facebbok. If the infidels don’t change their ways we will ban Microsoft also. Inshaallah!

  • its not a parameter to ban Facebook and youtube our government should talk to Americans and responsible’s for what they did and what they are doing banning anything is like something which is not acceptable facebok and youtube is also spreeding good thing which you all know

    • Bhai, money makes the world go. if America is paying mr. 100 percent, how can he even cough in american’s presence. shame on us, we are honorless people, we will sell our land, country, people, souls for $.

  • It is ludicrous to think that a towel head in Pakistan can shut down a weatern site. The only reason they can function at all is because they were taught English by the British and bought technology from the amerticans. More interest should be taken in trying to keep houses from crumbling when there is an earthquake.

    • @arnaux….you may not know this since you seem to be very uneducated…Asia runs western technology…look around you and tell me how many asians you see in western countries in technological industry

        • David, that is the kind of misinformation you have. Look up on google, and you will find more Pakistanis than Indians hold patents in IT. More Pakistanis run multi-million dollar companies and employ Americans than Indians. Indians have customer support and programming. Pakistanis are into innovation and creating new technologies.
          Dont forget the Pakistani doctors in America, the engineers who manufacture Boeing parts in Karachi, and ofcourse, the civilians who die in your “fake” wars. Typical “head in the ground” reply from a redneck. Go back to your tobacco and sister/mother , redneck.

          • — More Pakistanis run multi-million dollar companies and employ Americans than Indians.

            Seriously deluded. Seriously seriously.

            http://www.inc.com/vivek-wadhwa/how-the-indians-succeeded-in-silicon-valley.html

            — Pakistanis are into innovation and creating new technologies.

            What did we create in the past twenty years that the world is amazed at? N O T H I N G

            — Dont forget the Pakistani doctors in America, the engineers who manufacture Boeing parts in Karachi, and ofcourse, the civilians who die in your “fake” wars.

            Yeah, and also don’t forget that these companies have DEVELOPMENT offices in India: Google. Microsoft. Intel. Huawei. Hyundai. Panasonic. Abbott (yes, you buy their medicines here). GE. Infiniti. Philips. Yahoo.

            What do we have in Pakistan?

            • Shahid are you delusional? A Pakistani engineer invented a method through which you can run your car on pure water. This was also passed by the engineering and science council in Islamabad.

              /sarcasm.

              • RIGHT. IF WE STOP INVENTING AND IF OUR ENGINEERS AND DOCTORS RETURN HOME THE WESTERN COUNTRIES WILL DIE IN NO TIME. NASA WILL CRUMBLE IN 1 DAY!!! THAT WILL BE A GOOD LESSON FOR THEM FOR MAKING FUN OF MUSLIMS.

    • Hey arnaux, refresh my memory….didnt some towel heads put a mighty hole in the New York skyline? havent the same towel heads got you in deeper than you’d like to admit in Afganistan? didnt the same towel heads kill one of you in libya in magnificent fashion just a few days ago? Go run and hide behind a computer. Probably sh*t yourself to death if you ever saw a Muslim.

    • You mean the same technology that you stole from Muslim libraries a few centuries ago? Yea right, get your facts straight, infidel.

  • I do not follow your faith, and cannot speak to right or wrong in the actions of the newspaper, however preventing someone from viewing the cartoons seems silly. Do not let your personal ideologies prevent the greater human population from living life as they please.

    • live the way you want but do not hurt any bodys’ feelings, its like i discuss or defame your loved ones in the name of so called greater human intrest,

      • Then please stop being Muslims as this really hurts my feelings as an Infidel.

        Sorry, feelings are subjective and if they are hurt it’s your responsibility as an adult to find a way to deal with it in a mature way.

        • This is funny in fact. You make no sense. You will soon start to get hurt with me being a human being.

          As an adult you shouldn’t get hurt until someone offends you by addressing you or anything related to you.

          • > As an adult you shouldn’t get hurt until someone offends you by addressing you or anything related to you.

            The Qu’ran says plenty on infidels, which I happen to be, so there is your connection.

            If you think this is not insulting, because we infidels don’t rage and riot in front of your mosques, you are wrong. It’s just as insulting, we just deal with it like adults. There is also a difference between threats of violence and insults. The movie is just insulting, while the Qu’ran openly threatens me with violence and eternal torture.

            I also didn’t say that you shouldn’t be insulted or appeal to Youtubes policies, what I said that is that you shouldn’t threaten mayhem and murder because you are insulted. Like the Pakistani government has done and many other Islamic governments and organizations that want the creator and the actors executed.

            There is no excuse for violence and murder as a reaction to speech. Pakistan’s blasphemy law is a disgrace that does nothing than to tarnish the humanity of the Pakistani people.

            • >The Qu’ran says plenty on infidels, which I happen to be, so there is your connection.

              Since you don’t believe in Qu’ran, hence I don’t find a connection between you and whatever has been said in the book. You should have worried only if you have had believed in the book.

              Its like getting offended for something which doesn’t apply to you. Or if you believe that it applies to you, then Congratulations; you have started believing the verses.

              >what I said that is that you shouldn’t threaten mayhem and murder because you are insulted.

              i haven’t threatened anyone. I condemn such acts. All I seek is the justice – to trial the one who has made a movie which is spreading hatred, and is inflammatory.

              But unfortunately the judge will say that this movie comes under “Freedom of Speech and Press”, the same judge who would term Holocaust Denier a “Hate Speech”.

              You don’t believe me? Read this: https://propakistani.pk/2012/09/19/anti-islam-film-and-dual-standards-of-the-western-world/

              >There is no excuse for violence and murder as a reaction to speech.

              Agree, but only if justice is insured.

              >Pakistan’s blasphemy law is a disgrace that does nothing than to tarnish the humanity of the Pakistani people.

              Pakistan is an independent country which is governed by a law made by the parliament. People of this country are free to make rules (through their representatives) which they deem right. That’s exactly like any other democratic nation.

              This is exactly like the blasphemy law of Great Britain, or the Blasphemy laws which exist in several US states.

              You can learn more on these here:

              http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blasphemy_law_in_the_United_Kingdom
              http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Blasphemy_law_in_the_United_States

              • Pointing to how bad others are does nothing for your case. I know than Abrahamic religions and other ideologies have a hard time with people saying what they really think! The Us constitution was specifically created as a wall between government and the theocratic insanity that is Christianity and Islam

                > Pakistan is an independent country which is governed by a law made by the parliament. People of this country are free to make rules (through their representatives) which they deem right. That’s exactly like any other democratic nation.

                Obviously they can make whatever law they well please, that doesn’t make it just.

                Killing people for something they say, can never be justice.

                > Agree, but only if justice is insured.

                Your version of justice.

                > Since you don’t believe in Qu’ran, hence I don’t find a connection between you and whatever has been said in the book. You should have worried only if you have had believed in the book.

                Do you believe in the movie? Obviously you do not have to believe the message to recognize when you are insulted. As insults are subjective. Me being insulted by the Qu’ran is just as valid as you being insulted by a movie and without free speech it comes down to who is in power to enforce his version of justice on the one who is not.

                That is not justice, justice is dishing out punishments that fit the crime. A insult is not a crime and if it were, the punishment could not exceed the offence.

                • >Obviously they can make whatever law they well please, that doesn’t make it just. Killing people for something they say, can never be justice.

                  Your first sentence contradict the second.

                  >A insult is not a crime and if it were, the punishment could not exceed the offence.

                  How would you comment on Holocaust deniers, which I have heard are an Insult to the mankind? Should they be spared as well, just because anyone has a right to insult anyone (according to you)?

                  • Of course they should not be criminally punished. Just like Evolution deniers should not be criminally punished.

                  • > Your first sentence contradict the second.

                    No it doesn’t, it seems you confuse a law with justice, but a law does not automatically mean it is just. It means the state is enforcing an opinion on it’s citizens. Whether it is just depends on it fulfilling the principles of justice and fairness.

                    Look up Rawls “A Theory on Justice” The Muslims concept of justice is merely the attempt to impose the Islamic opinion on everyone, instead of applying principle of justice and fairness to everyone equally, which disqualifies any preference for a particular paradigm that does not treat everyone equally and is accessible to all of us through reason and empirical evidence.

                    That’s why things like blasphemy laws can never be just, since they assume the Islamic worldview to be correct and merely speaking against it a crime with punishments that are usually reserved for murderers in other societies.

            • “the Qu’ran openly threatens me with violence and eternal torture.”

              A very Friendly request to you that What ever you read about the eternal torture you should read with context , There Will be a lot of things told before this Specific thing. Do some research and come again to comment …

              • So what is the context that makes eternal torture for disbelieving OK? I’m rather curious since I’ve read what comes before and after and i can’t find any reason how eternal punishment for a finite offence can ever be justified. Let alone for disbelieving something for which there is no evidence and whose representatives are easily insulted by any imagined insult that would suggest that their religion might not be true after all.

                But then again I’m probably talking to someone who thinks that people should be killed if they insult Islam, so your measure of what is an appropriate punishment for an offence is probably way different than mine.

            • Mr Daniel
              Yes you are right in a sense that at places in Quran God tells people about the punishments given to them in the hereafter as an outcome of what they did in this world.My dear brother through Quran, Your and Mine God is trying to save us from the fire which will be in hell and the punishment given by the creator of all the universe and every thing else and the punishment will be never ending.

              Your statement that you feel threatened by the verses is not realistic. You feel them threatening by the verses you mentioned but few verses of Quran are understood in a context only.

              I request you to save your spirit and soul from the never ending punishment and live your short life in this world according to will of your creator and not by your own will and decisions. Believe in me if you surrender your self in the court of your creator you will be satisfied and most lucky person.

              • It seems all becoming a Muslim does is make you angry about stupid movies. I don’t wanna riot in the streets and demand the death of people who i don’t agree with. So no thank you. The maker of the movie just as you, believes his message is right.

                Every speech can insult someone as we all have a different perspective on life, that’s why after thousands of years of burning dissenters on the stake, we finally stopped. It is time that Muslims accept that their speech is not the only valid one and that you can’t just kill everyone you think insults your religion. AS that is the much greater insult to your religion and much more important, your humanity.

          • Hey admin, I would seriously love to see you live as a minority Muslim in the West for a few years, and see how badly you lose arguments about our religion.

            Because that seems to be the only way you’ll FINALLY UNDERSTAND the difference between PRIDE and HUMILITY.

        • NITED NATIONS: U.N. Secretary-General Ban Ki-moon said on Wednesday the maker of an anti-Islam film that triggered violent protests across the Muslim world abused his right to freedom of expression by making the movie, which he called a “disgraceful and shameful act.”

          freedoms of expression should be and must be guaranteed and protected, when they are used for common justice, common purpose,” Ban told a news conference.

          “When some people use this freedom of expression to provoke or humiliate some others’ values and beliefs, then this cannot be protected in such a way.”

          “My position is that freedom of expression, while it is a fundamental right and privilege, should not be abused by such people, by such a disgraceful and shameful act,” he said

          for you Daniel

          • Yes, abused his freedom of speech right. But note he did not say he wanted restrictions posed on freedom of speech. He just said it should not be abused.

            Meaningless statement.

    • we want to see the denial of holocaust on youtube. but my friend “pragmatic one” i was not able to find it on youtube…n u knw y….because it was removed by the youtube. sooooooooooo when u try to post a coment….post it sensibly…

      it was the jewish personal interest tht the video got removed frm youtube. now it is the honor of Prophet Muhammad S.A.W so we will not step behinde. better search first then post coments…

    • Pragmatic, Islam is the 2nd largest religion in the world, and like it or not, but you greatly hurt all of us. We probably are more united on certain principles than Christian/Jewish sects. COnsidering this, I’d say the greater human population (purely on numbers) is hurt right now, and hurt real bad. Half of the non muslims are already split about this film/cartoons, I dont think that purely on the basis of numbers you can say that more people are ‘enjoying’ this heinous act.
      Make fun of us, our countries, our habits all you like – but religion is STRICTLY off limits.
      Speaking of which, why dont you people let anyone make a movie, or even “talk” in public about the holocaust? Can you justify that?

      • Imran, I am perhaps most confused by this issue because religion of anyone is nothing more than a habit of spiritual practice. I do not understand why mocking an individual’s nationality or habits seems to be ok, but religion seems to invoke an entirely different reaction. Why the greatly different reaction. Is satire, not simply satire?

        I do see the paper’s actions as something that was done to simply invoke a reaction and was unnecessary. I’m seeking to understand why such a reaction can be elicited by just posting an image.

  • I am Very happy to See that kind of Sprit, this is the moderate Protest, i love i love it, i love it very much, God Bless you“Guardian of Honor of Prophet SAW”.

  • KI MUHAMMAD(S.A.W.W) SAY WAFA TU NAY TO HM TERAY HAI
    YE JAHAN CHEEZ HAI KYA, LOH O QALAM TERAY HAIN

    MASHAALLAH ,VERY NICE WORK…

    • Its down again with a more massive attack and we will make sure to keep it down for whatever time we can.

  • It’s sad that you can be that smart and that stupid at the same time. Usually hackers are on the site of free information and free speech against powerful interest, but they are the exact opposite.

    Just because you don’t like speech, doesn’t mean you should prohibit it, this protects everybodies speech. I’m insulted by the content of the Qu’Ran but i wouldn’t even dream of banning it, no matter how insulting and threatening it is to infidels. I feel sorry that you are so insecure in your faith that the words of others represent such a threat to your faith

    • then why the denial of holocuast animated movie was removed from the youtube…??? jst tell me………telll ussssssssss

      the one who posted the video has complete freedom of speech…then yyyyyyyyyyy on earth that movie was removed frm the youtube…
      jst because it was against the interest of people like u and the jewssssss..

      i am also sorry for you that the so called freedom of speech is only true for you mr daienl….and not for others including the one who posted a movie denial of holocaust on youtube……..

      better keep ur words and thoughts checked…….before you post a coment….

      I AM SORRY BUT YOU PEOPLE HAVE DUAL STANDARDS.

      I FEEL PITY FOR YOU….CH CH CH CH

      • I don’t know what youtube’s policies are. I don’t know what movie you are talking about, but i doubt that there were mobs of people rioting burning embassies and murdering unrelated innocent people, threatening to murder the creators of the movies or governments demanding the punishment and public execution of those involved. So please a little perspective.

        No one says you have to like the movie.

      • Also who is you people? I don’t represent anyone but myself and i would speak out against anyone that reacted in such a way as we saw this last week!

    • >>>>>> Just because you don’t like speech, doesn’t mean you should prohibit it, this protects everybodies speech. <<<<<>>>>> I’m insulted by the content of the Qu’Ran but i wouldn’t even dream of banning it, no matter how insulting and threatening it is to infidels.<<<<<<

      Holy Qur'an do not humiliate a single person not even animals or any other creature.First read The Holy Qur'an thoroughly and then comment.

      • Oh really?

        Quran (3:56) – “As to those who reject faith, I will punish them with terrible agony in this world and in the Hereafter, nor will they have anyone to help.”

        Quran (8:12) – “I will cast terror into the hearts of those who disbelieve. Therefore strike off their heads and strike off every fingertip of them” No reasonable person would interpret this to mean a spiritual struggle.

        Quran (9:29) – “Fight those who believe not in Allah nor the Last Day, nor hold that forbidden which hath been forbidden by Allah and His Messenger, nor acknowledge the religion of Truth, (even if they are) of the People of the Book, until they pay the Jizya with willing submission, and feel themselves subdued

        Obviously I don’t believe in Allah, nor his messenger, nor do I acknowledge that Islam has any truth to it and I certainly don’t want to pay the Jizya and feel myself subdued, i want to live as equals with every human being, free to criticize and satirize ideas and in return have my ideas criticized and satirized.

        This are only 3 from a great litany of insulting and threatening verses, so please come down from your high horse. Free speech protects everyone, as those verses do not actually harm me, only when Muslims act on it, but than it has left the realm of free speech altogehter.

        As I said free speech protects everyone, since i do not want to dependent on the whims of whoever is in authority and whatever this person or group of people deems acceptable to say. You might find yourself on the wrong end of that bargain.

        The movie didn’t harm your religion, how could it. It’s your religion only you can harm it through your conduct. What weak faith can be attacked by a movie?

        • First two verses are behavioral and are conventional for Holy books including Torah and Bible.

          These verses (and many others available in all Holy books) explain to non-believers to accept Allah and day of judgment but clearly they aren’t imposed. You are free to adopt them or otherwise just let them go away if you choose so.

          Third verse is about a law for (then) Muslim states in which non-Muslims chose to live, for which they weren’t forced – but they could live if they wanted. For such non-Muslims who wanted to reside in Muslim states with all the rights had to pay Jizya (taxes) to avail all the rights. Its exactly like the taxes you pay (assuming you aren’t from Belgium).

          ——————————

          Now to next part of your comment.

          -The movie didn’t harm your religion, how could it. It’s your religion only you can harm it through your conduct. What weak faith can be attacked by a movie?

          Movie can’t harm a religion, especially if its Islam. Its not the religion that’s harmed, rather they are feeling which got hurt. Exactly, if someone make nude drawings of your kid in objectionable styles. He/she won’t do any damages to your kid or you – rather it will hurt your feelings; and you will do anything to stop such acts.

          -As I said free speech protects everyone, since i do not want to dependent on the whims of whoever is in authority and whatever this person or group of people deems acceptable to say.

          If so, then why Azhar Ahmed, 19, was charged when he updated his Facebook status as “all soldiers should die and go to hell”, when six British solders had died in Afghanistan. The court said that his communication was “derogatory” and “inflammatory”.

          Complete story is available here: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-england-leeds-19604735

          I am wondering, how in this world this blasphemous movie isn’t derogatory and inflammatory?

          • I’m not the judge and i don’t represent all of western culture as you seem to believe. If I had heard of this case I would have written a similar defense of free soeech, similar because native Brits didn’t riot in the streets and demand that Azhar Ahmed be executed.

            There is still a difference in the reaction, even though I also don’t agree with it.

            • Denial, British didn’t riot in the streets because Azhar was already charged. But here in this case, the creator and actor aren’t charged yet.. All the protest and riots in muslim world are to bring them to court and bring down those videos, cartoons and movies just like the the pages and videos in favor of Hitler are taken down of these social websites.

              • — But here in this case, the creator and actor aren’t charged yet..

                There isn’t an authority in the States that can charge the creator of the movie. It doesn’t fit into the concept of “hate crime” because no living Muslim is being attacked.

                • A crime is usually when another human being is harmed. If you don’t harm another human being, why would it be a crime? Muslims where not harmed by the movie, they chose how to react to the movie, they chose to burn embassies, to kill others, all things which do actual harm. All because of a movie most of them didn’t even see and before they freaked out, no one had seen. The movie did not harm anyone, Muslims however did.

                  If the movie is a hate crime, so is the Qu’ran with it’s message of hate against unbelievers and unbelievers.

                  • >> If the movie is a hate crime, so is the Qu’ran with it’s message of hate against unbelievers and unbelievers. <<

                    How Holy Qur'an spread message of hate against anyone? Holy Qur'an ordered its believers to not to harm any single Innocent human ( whether they are Muslim or non-Muslim), and by any means (by your words, by your act,physically or mentally). Read Holy Qur'an with open heart.Qur'an presents best solution to all human matters.Qur'an spread message of peace to all human.Qur'an do not order to kill non-believers.Qur'an do not allow to force any one to become Muslim.
                    Qur'an talks about punishment of non-believers in many versus and these punishments will be given by ALLAH on the judgement day.This is not a hate speech.Many types of punishments are found in laws of all religions and countries (including death penalties). Now will you say that all laws in the world are hate speech?

                    Qur'an do not ordered death penalty to non-believers. Qur'an advised its believers to behave equally with minorities.Any kind of hatred act is not allowed with anyone.

                    But in that video Prophet is shown doing sex and it includes other hatred scenes.It is full of humiliation.If that kind of hatred film was released about obama or any usa national hero like Lincoln then it would have been banned.

                  • Daniel, I’ve been looking at your posts. First you make negative comments (without knowledge). When they are justified, and similar examples of hate against Muslims are given, you claim “i dont know”, “i wasnt the judge”, “i dont know what youtube policies are”. Real mature. So here goes:

                    “We dont know anything about any site being hacked. We think the Israelis did this to blame Muslims. You should check Israel’s policy on hacking. We dont know.”

                    • Dude, have you contered with a POSITIVE comment in such a way to invite Daniel to Islam?

                      N

                      O

                      People who live in glass houses, etc etc.

    • >>>>>> Just because you don’t like speech, doesn’t mean you should prohibit it, this protects everybodies speech. <<<<<<

      It is not just an ordinary speech we do not like.There is a lots of stuff on web which many of us might not like but no one demands to block it. Specially billions of humans altogether do not demand any thing else to blocked.

      This is indeed extreme hate speech and hate speech is prohibited all over the world and on all major online platforms.This stuff is hurting billions of humans altogether.But thing is these billions are Muslim.If there would be only few Jews or Americans instead of Muslims in this hatred situation then circumstances would be certainly different.

    • YES. TAKE DOWN INFIDEL YOUTUBE, GOOGLE, BBC, MICROSOFT, DISH TV, COMPUTERS… NOT ONLY FOR A FEW DAYS BUT FOREVER. DESTROY THE RETARDED WORLD!
      MUSLIMS CREATED ALL THIS BUT IT WAS HIJACKED BY THE WEST. NOW OUR SUPER HACKERS ARE ON WORK!!
      WE WILL CREATE ANOTHER INTERNET WHICH WILL BE TRUE PRO PAKISTANI ISLAMIC INTERNET!!!
      INSHAALLAH.


  • >