Latest News Cricket Football Hockey Combat Sports E-Sports Champions Trophy 2025 PSL 2025 Other Sports Careers

Third Umpire Faces Scrutiny After Unfair Dismissal of Smith and Stoinis

Australian players and coach have spoken up about losing Steve Smith and Marcus Stoinis due to unclear umpiring decisions in their match against South Africa in Lucknow.

In a high-stakes encounter at the ICC Cricket World Cup, the third umpire’s decisions during the Australia-South Africa match have come under scrutiny, sparking debates and conversations among cricket enthusiasts. The match, played in Lucknow, witnessed two contentious dismissals that left players and coaches with mixed feelings.

Firstly, Marcus Stoinis was adjudged caught behind, despite video replays suggesting that his hand had let go of the bat handle when the ball brushed his glove. Third umpire Richard Kettleborough’s decision was met with disbelief by Stoinis. Marnus Labuschagne, who witnessed the incident, expressed his opinion, saying, “It looked like there was clear daylight between the two gloves and the handle.”

The second dismissal involved star batter Steve Smith, who was given out lbw after ball-tracking technology indicated the delivery would have hit the top of the left stump. Smith, visibly unconvinced, raised doubts about the decision. Australia’s head coach Andrew McDonald claimed that Steve Smith and Marcus Stoinis’s presence on the crease could have made a difference.

Despite the controversy, Australia suffered a 134-run defeat, leaving them winless in the tournament.

Stay Connected with ProPakistani

Get the latest sports news, match updates, and player stories wherever you prefer.

Add ProPakistani to Preferred Sources and see more of our stories in Google Search and Top Stories.


  • Steven Smith’s decision was the first one and not the second.
    Plus the ball was hitting the top of right meaning leg stump and not the left.
    Kindly correct your facts before posting something. Don’t just post it for the sake of it.


  • Get Alerts

    ProPakistani Community

    Join the groups below to get latest news and updates.



    >